Critical Evaluation Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 1

Critical Evaluation - Essay ExampleFocusing too much on Pachecos argument that Behns novella is Eurocentric and class-biased, the review fails to provide a balanced view of Pachecos commentary, and leaves the reader clueless about Pachecos objective in penning the essay exposing the political agenda underlying Behns novella, and its failure in achieving an ideological closure.The review begins with a clearly stated objective of exploring the main points of Pachecos essay and analysing its strengths and weaknesses however, proceeds to describe Pachecos arguments and illustrations that suggest Behns hero as Eurocentric and royalist. A significant portion of the review is spent on summarising Pachecos viewpoints, and presents little attempt to analyse or interpret Pachecos observation in the backdrop of her thesis or the primary text. At legion(predicate) places like when describing Pachecos comments on Europeanizing the African and Behns approach to slavery, the reviewer simply repea ts Pachecos words as in a simple storey of the article, without quoting the author, or interpreting the implications of Pachecos observations. The review is totally oblivious of Pachecos commentary on Oroonokos treatment of honour and its instability within the upper-class/royalist discourse due to the religious implications, which according to her eventually leads to the undermining of the novels royalist ideology. While the review provides crucial insights into the perspective of Pachecos analysis, it does non endeavour to assess or evaluate the strength or weakness of her claims or offer a comprehensive framework for the readers to make the assessment themselves.though the reviewer make a note of other works that substantiate Pachecos thesis such as that by Guffey, the commentary fails to provide a comparative perspective with other works for the reader to assess the merit and significance of Pachecos study. The